The World Thru My Eyes - I speak my mind and man does it like to talk.
This is sad
Published on August 22, 2007 By CharlesCS In Politics
In a story that’s been going on for years now, a woman called Elvira Arellano, an illegal immigrant from Mexico made her way to the US many years ago like so many others. She was already deported once but managed to make her way back to the US; but this time she managed to get a job cleaning airplanes at the Chicago Airport with a fake Social Security number. At the same time Elvira gave birth to her son Saul here in the US making him an American citizen.

The FBI tried to take Elvira in for using fake documents but Elvira sought refuge in a church. She stayed there for a while but eventually took a trip to L.A. where she was picked up by ICE and deported back to Mexico. She left her son in the hands on the people of the church. Walter Colman, Pastor, Adalberto United Methodist church where Elvira was spoke to Hannity from FoxNews about them hiding a criminal. Coleman began by stating that Elvira was invited by American companies to come to the US to work for them but Hannity corrected him. Then when Hannity referred to Elvira as a criminal Coleman went off saying “that everybody in this country has broken that law”. Somehow in the eyes of a religious person 2 wrongs do make a right. It makes me wonder if we should allow people who “suffer” poverty “due to the US Gov’t” to steal and not arrest and prosecute them. I mean, after all, according to this Priest “everybody in this country has broken that law” and therefore they should not be punished for it.

The biggest problem with Elvira is not that she is an illegal immigrant; the real problem is that she managed to use fake identification to get a job at an airport working directly inside airplanes. This poses a major security risk, allowing illegal immigrants to work at airports under fake Social Security numbers would make it easy for terrorists to plant bombs on planes and cause chaos in the US once again and the reason the FBI was involved. Elvira, now In Tijuana Mexico, has now joined a Rights Group that defends illegal immigrants and had vowed to fight for her right to be in the US because her son is an American citizen.

To make things more interesting, now all of a sudden those who defend illegal immigrants such as Elvira are calling her the new Rosa Parks. Rosa Parks? A legal American citizen born and raise in the US, Rosa Parks fought for civil rights. She fought to get the rights that, as an American citizen, she deserved. Rosa Parks was not an illegal immigrant, did not break any laws. According to the ordinance n2. Section 10, Chapter 6, Code of the City of Montgomery,

Every person operating a bus line in the city shall provide equal but separate accommodations for white people and negroes on his buses, by requiring the employees in charge thereof to assign passengers seats on the vehicles under their charge in such manner as to separate the white people from the negroes, where there are both white and negroes on the same car;


Equal but separate, not more for whites than blacks. Further more Section 11, Chapter 6, Code of the City of Montgomery further states:

Any employee in charge of a bus operated in the city shall have the powers of a police officer of the city while in actual charge of any bus, for the purpose of carrying out the provisions of the preceding section, and it shall be unlawful for any passenger to refuse or fail to take a seat among those assigned to the race to which he belongs, at the request of any such employee in charge, if there is such a seat vacant.'


In other words she could not refuse if she was in the “white only” section while there was a vacant seat in the “negroes” section. The bus driver had moved the “whites only” section back to include Rosa Parks seat and there were no other seats left on the bus, according to the story. This is not a woman posing a security risk to the entire nation or taking advantage of a system illegally. This was a woman who fought for rights she felt she deserved since she, like everyone else, was an American citizen.

So how can Emma Lozano, executive director of Centro Sin Fronteras, which is an immigrant rights group (not illegal immigrants rights group, interesting how they chose to fight for criminals as oppose to those entering legally), claim “Elvira has a message. What would you do if they wanted you to leave your child behind? She can't do that. So she chose to stand up. Similarly what Rosa Parks did, from not getting up anymore to give her seat to someone. And she's saying this is wrong, fix it. And everybody's trying to fix it. So why deport her now?” as if Elvira and Rosa were on the same page, in the same league?

Rosa Parks was charged with a crime that she did not deserve and fought because she felt she deserved better treatment as a legal citizen. Elvira was deported for false SS documents and entering the US illegally and is fighting for rights she does not have since she is not a legal citizen of the US? I’m sorry, but Elvira is no Rosa Parks and I am sad to think Rosa’s name is being stained with the acts of a criminal who broke the law not once but twice not for her people but for selfish reasons.

I am even more ashamed that a Priest would ignore the crimes of a person and hide them from the Authorities. Who are they to decide whether a person should be prosecuted or not in a democratic country?


Links to my sources:



Link

Link

Link

Link


Comments
on Aug 22, 2007
Why is it so hard for these people to understand the word "illegal"?  
on Aug 22, 2007
Why is it so hard for these people to understand the word "illegal"?


Go figure, I've always said people don't usually care about something until it affects them directly. This is a shame as far as I'm concerned, she is no Rosa Parks, she is not defending her American rights. She's not even fighting for those of her child.
on Aug 22, 2007
I didn't hear about this Charles, thanks for writing about it. I do agree with the authorities who deported her. The fact is she did use illegal documents which is fraud. She should be deported just like anyone who do it and are caught and returned to their homeland once the long arms of the law catches up to them. She chose not to take her son with her, who could be with his mom and who I'm sure won't lose his citizenship and would be able to return when he's older and then he can file for her. I guess time is something she is not willing to wait on.
on Aug 22, 2007
I didn't hear about this Charles, thanks for writing about it. I do agree with the authorities who deported her. The fact is she did use illegal documents which is fraud. She should be deported just like anyone who do it and are caught and returned to their homeland once the long arms of the law catches up to them. She chose not to take her son with her, who could be with his mom and who I'm sure won't lose his citizenship and would be able to return when he's older and then he can file for her. I guess time is something she is not willing to wait on.


No problem. When I heard this on the news I flipped. Not only did she enter the country illegally twice but also used illegal documents to get a job at an airport. Does she not watch the news about terrorist? Does she not care that she is giving terrorist the tools necessary to possible kill her own child? And the audacity to compare her to Rosa Parks, how dare they?

The saddest part is that these people, the illegal immigrants who claim to fight for immigrants rights, because they never join illegal immigrant rights groups, they are always immigrant rights groups, don't care about the legal immigrants who have to pay outrageous amounts of money and waste outrageous amounts of time year after year just so they can call themselves American Citizen, pay large amounts of taxes, be called war-mongers, have terrorist kill them and be insulted but foreign bloggers. they on the other hand are offered a $1000 find, a slap on the hand and a social security number so they can go ahead and claim for stuff like welfare, medicare and stuff. What great people are we, right? I wonder why terrorist think we such bad people?
on Aug 22, 2007
Hey yall

Been a while, but nice article and well written.
She should be deported no question, and the people calling her Rosa Parks are just grandstanding.

The real way to stop illegal workers is to push the companies severely, but give those companies a way to truly know if a potential worker is legal or not.
on Aug 22, 2007

I am even more ashamed that a Priest would ignore the crimes of a person and hide them from the Authorities.

He was not hiding her.  He was granting her sanctuary.  WHile I do not agree with him on his rationale, I fully support his right to sanctuary.  Within his creed.  As you saw, he was following his faith, not the laws of the land.  And while we can in this instance disagree with him, we must defend him and his decision to grant sanctuary.  The alternative is to ignore what happened in Nazi Germany 70 years ago, since at the time, it was a democracy.

on Aug 22, 2007
He was not hiding her. He was granting her sanctuary. WHile I do not agree with him on his rationale, I fully support his right to sanctuary. Within his creed. As you saw, he was following his faith, not the laws of the land. And while we can in this instance disagree with him, we must defend him and his decision to grant sanctuary. The alternative is to ignore what happened in Nazi Germany 70 years ago, since at the time, it was a democracy.


I understand what you mean, but in a society where the law applies even if it was done for religious reasons we should not be allowing criminals to hide (or find sanctuary) behind Gods robes. I have to believe that God did not intend to defend the guilty. I won't take away the Priest's right to his belief, but I have to believe that apart from keeping a criminal from the hands of the law and then go on to justify the crimes simply because others have done it are not or should not be the beliefs of a man of God. I hope you don't really believe we are anything like Nazi Germany, even in this kind of situation where a person committed a crime, broke a law and like any and every other criminal in jail or out of jail should be punished. If I was to hide her based on my religious beliefs I would be charged with aiding and abetting a criminal and interfering with police business.
on Aug 22, 2007
should not be allowing criminals to hide (or find sanctuary) behind Gods robes.


"We" did not. She was arrested. But do not fault him for his actions, just the idiocy of his statements.
on Aug 22, 2007
She's not much of a poster child. The whole story of "I'm being forced away from my child" is pure BS. Like FS said, if she wanted to be with her son, she would take him with her to Mexico. He will not lose his citizenship and can always move back to the U.S. as an adult if he chooses.
on Aug 22, 2007
sorry Church's have always offered sanctuary to non violent criminals. at least for negotiations reasons.
on Aug 22, 2007
"We" did not. She was arrested. But do not fault him for his actions, just the idiocy of his statements.


I can agree with that.

Now you see the above statement of mine? Why can't people like Col gene, ziggy, ThinkAloud, and a few others actually see that their points of view could be changed if you listen to other peoples ideas or opinions and take them into consideration as oppose to sticking to what you believe in and ignore a decent debate?